I should have known then. Diagonal toast is a choice, and Gary made it every single morning, loudly, with the big knife, while I stood there holding the small knife, the correct knife, saying nothing.
Gary also put the toaster on 5. Not once. Every time. He said 3.5 “was not a number.” He was technically right, and it was the beginning of the end.
When we separated, Gary took the car, the good blender, the dog (who chose him, and whom I do not blame) and our joint subscription to a meal-kit service. He also asked for the toaster.